Skip to content

On the guess · Check, correct or withdraw what it guessed. · it guesses

Element 67

67◕›
El
Explain

Ask why it guessed that.

why? · why am I seeing this

First known

Opened

1975MYCIN: type WHY and it says why it is asking; type HOW and it says how it reached a conclusion. Davis, Buchanan and Shortliffe, Stanford.

See also: SHRDLU answers 'why did you do that?' with its goal: 'TO CLEAN OFF THE RED CUBE' (Winograd, MIT, January 1971).

“Because the consultation process is essentially one of search through an AND/OR goal tree, ... WHY a question was asked, and HOW a conclusion was (or will be) reached.”

MYCIN's guesses are about a patient, not about you, so it is the ancestor of asking a machine why.

Someone opened the dated document itself. The source.

  • ReadingValue

Specimen № 67 — operate freely

Tap why? on a post. Then ask why again, and once more.

Fig. 67 — Explain

000 readings · idle

On the guess: its twin

  1. on the guessElExplain
  2. on the errandRpReport

The two series line up in pairs. Each act on a guess sits above the act that does the same thing to an errand, so Explain and Report are one move made on two kinds of thing.

Bodies

The act stays put while the hardware changes. These are some of the forms Explain takes.

  • why?
  • why am I seeing this